Catholic & Protestant Approaches to the Bible
Response to comment [from other]: "Martin Luther started the concept of Sola Scriptura."
Tell the prophet Isaiah that (Is.
55:11).
Ps 119:130.
The Protestant Reformation was necessary.
See:
Martin Luther: Passionate
Reformer
Watch the movie Luther (2003). Cruciform, you are the bad guy (Eph 4:14).
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: ""...Protestant doctrinal chaos...some 38,000 competing non-Catholic denominations and sects...their own ideosyncratic theological opinions, with more being invented every week. Brilliant."
Too bad you're a legalist. "Too bad." ~
Seth Brundle, The Fly
One of the most helpful and profound statements I have read in recent years for
the understanding of contemporary church life is by Leith Anderson. He notes,
While the New Testament speaks often about churches, it is surprisingly silent
about many matters that we associate with church structure and life. There is no
mention of architecture, pulpits, lengths of typical sermons (or sermons!],
rules for having a Sunday school. Little is said about style of music, order of
worship, or times of church gatherings. There were no Bibles, denominations,
camps, pastors conferences, or board meeting minutes. Those who strive to be
New Testament churches must seek to live its principles and absolutes, not
reproduce the details.
Those details simply arent given.
Now you might ask yourself, Why does the New Testament say nothing about all
those matter to which the usual congregation today devotes almost all its
thought and effort? Answer: Because those matters are not primary and will
take care of themselves with little attention whenever what is primary is
appropriately cared for. Pay attention to the principles and absolutes of the
New Testament church and, one might suppose, everything else will fall into
placein large part because everything else really doesnt matter much one way
or the other. To fail to put the focus on those principles and absolutes, on the
other hand, is to wander off into a state of distraction, which is where most of
our local congregations actually are. They wind up majoring on minors and
allowing the majors, from the New Testament point of view, to disappear
(Willard, pg. 235-236).
"...[E]vasive non-answer"
Do you have faith in the wisdom of men or in the power of God? 1 Cor 2:4-5. Are you in love with your church or with the Lord Jesus? "...[A]void making the vessel the treasure. We can identify the treasure without reference to any vessel, though the treasure will always have a vessel (Willard, pg. 239)."
Objective truth comes from God's word (2 Tim. 2:15; Jas. 1:18). Men lie (Ga 1:6-8, Mt 15:9, Eph 4:14). :olinger: God does not (Nu 23:19). :Poly:
"Sometimes the church needs division. Without division they cannot have multiplication." ~ Woodrow Kroll Jude 16
Response to comment [from other]: "I wanted to be a cop when I grew up, do you just hope to make your own arguments?"
Grow up then reapply. I believe they have mental stability requirements.
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: [Do you have faith in the wisdom of men or in the power of God? 1 Cor 2:4-5.] "Do you have faith in the wisdom of men...or in the wisdom of God..."
I have faith in God's wisdom (1
Sa 2:3;
Job 9:4). It is perfect (Job
36:4;
37:16). Your Pope
is
not perfect.
Yours is mindless wisdom (e.g. making decisions without rational, logical
reasoning). What makes you a superstitious mystic is that you believe things
apart from evidence (Ferguson).
We call you Cruci-form-of-godliness-but-denying-the-power-thereof
(2
Ti 3:5) because you trust in men's wisdom. A
Christian would have said he trusts in the power of God (1
Cor 2:4-5). Men lie (Ga
1:6-8,
Mt 15:9,
Eph 4:14). God does not (Nu
23:19).
"Are you in love with your preferred non-Catholic doctrinal tradition..."
I love the truth (Jn 1:1). Why don't you? Jn 3:19. Why do you tolerate these false teachings from your church?
"...[S]erpent's interpretations of the bible are lies."
You'd better check for yourself against God's word (Ac 17:11). Where I depart from the word of God, reject what I say (1 Cor 2:1).
"The Pope, however, does teach infallibly with respect to formal Christian doctrine."
They teach error well (Ga
5:9).
See:
No Idolatry & False Teaching
False Catholic Traditions
Knowledge is not enough. Even the demons have that and so
does the
Pope (Jas
2:19).
You need knowledge, insight, and finally intimacy. You cannot be saved until you
understand the gospel of grace (Ezr
7:25, Gen.
15:6; Gen.
20:6; Deut.
7:69; Deut.
9:46; Job
10:12; Job
22:2, 3; Psa.
94:1719; Psa.
138:3; Psa.
143:11; Dan.
9:18; Dan.
10:18, 19; John
6:44, 45; John
17:11, 12, 15; Acts
4:29, 30; Acts
26:22; Rom.
3:2224; Rom.
4:4, 16; Rom.
5:2, 68, 1521; Rom.
9:1016; Rom.
11:5, 6; 1
Cor. 1:48; 1
Cor. 10:13; 1
Cor. 15:10; 2
Cor. 1:12; Gal.
1:14, 16; Eph.
1:59, 11, 12; Eph.
2:8, 9; Eph.
3:16; Eph.
4:7; Eph.
6:10; Phil.
1:19; Phil.
2:13; 1
Thess. 1:1 1
Thess. 5:28; 2
Pet. 1:2; 1
Tim. 1:14; 2
Tim. 1:1, 9; Tit.
3:7; 1
Pet. 1:5; 1
Pet. 4:10; 1
Pet. 5:10; Jude
1, 21, 24, 25; Rev.
3:10).
See:
Audio Pt
7a,
7b, From the Series:
Loving God with all your Heart by Dr. Darrell Ferguson
(right click, open)
"...[Y]ou ultimately trust in your own theological preferences and opinions---that is, in "men's wisdom.""
I ultimately use my
brain.
Love the Lord with all your heart, soul and mind. (Mk 12:30).
"Every verse of the Bible means exactly what the author intended it to mean..."
Full text:
How to Interpret the Bible by Darrell Ferguson
See:
Hermeneutics
"...[S]erpent is a man; therefore, serpent is lying. For that matter, the apostles were men; therefore, the apostles were lying."
Christ taught out of the scriptures, he must have been
lying, too (Lk
24:27).
For the Catholic, man's word is the final authority.
For the Christian, God's word is the final authority.
"We have different authorities, we believe different gospels, we worship
different Christs, we are led by different spirits and we are on different paths
to eternity. Compare this with the unity the apostle Paul described with those
who are in one body and one ......Spirit, with one hope; one Lord, one faith,
one baptism, on God and Father of all who is over all and through all and in all
(Eph
4:4-6)..." Full text:
No Idolatry & False Teaching
[Check God's word for yourself] "I do---just not against serpent's favored
interpretations of God's word. Big difference there."
Love God with all your mind (Ps 104:34). The scriptures are full and sufficient (Lk 16:29,31), an unerring guide (Pr 6:23; 2 Pe 1:19), able to make men wise unto salvation through faith in Christ Jesus (2 Ti 3:15).
[Where I depart from the word of God, reject what I say.] "I do, which is why I'm a Catholic."
Plenty of Catholics will go to hell (plenty of Protestants will too by the way). We don't go to heaven or hell based on church affiliation. We go to heaven or hell based on a right relationship with Jesus Christ (Isa 45:25; 53:11). Get to know him in his word (Phil 3:8). You cannot love God without your mind (Eph 1:17).
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: "[W]hy are there numerous "Christian" denominations?"
"To answer this question, we
must first differentiate between denominations within the body of Christ and
non-Christian cults and false religions..." Full text:
Why are there so many Christian denominations?
There are two types of people--the righteous and the wicked. We have no
righteousness of our own (Job
15:14;
Ps 14:3;
Ro 3:10). No one will be
justified by their "good" works (Ro
3:20;
9:31,32;
Ga 2:16). No one will be
saved by their "good" works (Eph
2:8,9;
2 Ti 1:9;
Tit 3:5). Unregenerate
men
are stuck
on stupid
(Lu 18:9;
Ro 10:3). We must be
found in Christ (Isa
45:24;
54:17;
2 Co 5:21). Saints have
his righteousness imputed (Ro
4:11,22).
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: "...[C]ontradicting doctrines can't all be equally authoritative. So whose interpretation is correct, and how do we know?"
Study (2 Ti 2:5).
Don't be lazy (Mt 7:14) and don't be impressed by
appearances (Jude 16 [lusts here: earthly, sensual, demonic]).
The path to God never violates wisdom. Which passage of the Bible can you
understand without your mind? None. Ferguson. 1 Jn 5:20
See:
Audio Pt
7a,
7b, From the Series:
Loving God with all your Heart by Dr. Darrell Ferguson
(right click, open)
"So two mutually exclusive Biblical interpretations are both correct?"
Hermeneutics must be more than "because that guy said so." Ac 17:11
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: "You listen to the Pope for what you are to believe! You will go to hell, here look what [Darrell] Ferguson has to say about it!"
I thought you hated people in white pointy hats (Mt 15:9, Eph 4:14, Re 17:1-6).
"...I mediated between three KKK leaders, and three former Black Panters from MLK's days..."
You're so much cooler online ( Brad Paisley). If pastor Ferguson wore a white pointy hat would you believe everything he said? Rev. 3:1422
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: "...[Y]our preferred Protestant anti-Catholic doctrinal tradition..."
"You keep using that word. I do not think it means, what you think it means." ~
Inigo Montoya
The proper question is: What hermeneutic do you use?
"...[A]ffirmation of the ancient heresy of Ecclesial Deism..."
Strawman.
God is sovereign (Dan.
4:25,
35;
Rom. 9:1523;
1 Tim. 6:15;
Rev. 4:11). His word is
living and active in the life of the believer (Heb.
4:12). The Lord continues to build his church (Mt
16:18). God's word (not your
perversion and inversion of it) is effectual (Is.
55:11).
"...[I]t isn't enough to have a good mind; one must also know how to use
it."
You are expected to use it (1
Jn 5:20).
"When you educate without the Holy Spirit, you only get a clever devil." ~
Adrian Rogers
"...[N]ot what serpent insists that it means."
"Every verse of the Bible means
exactly what the author intended it to mean..." Full text:
How to Interpret the Bible by Darrell Ferguson
See:
Hermeneutics
"...[A]uthoritative teachings of the apostles' successors..."
"...[N]owhere in Scripture did Jesus, the apostles, or any other New Testament writer set forth the idea of apostolic succession. Further, neither is Peter presented as supreme over the other apostles..." Full text: Is apostolic succession biblical?
"You'll have to come up with some other means of undermining the authority of Christ's historic Church...and, thus, of Christ himself..."
It is wicked to change the glory of
God into an image (Ro
1:23;
Ac 17:29). It is wicked
to worship the true God by an image (Ex
32:4-6;
Ps 106:19,20).
See:
No
Sacrifice
Which Jesus Will You Trust?
No Altering Commandments
No Idolatry & False Teaching
"...[T]he biblical documents themselves were written by men."
The scriptures were given by
inspiration of God (2
Ti 3:16). Men wrote under the inspiration of
the Holy Spirit (Ac
1:16;
Heb 3:7;
2 Pe 1:21).
See:
Why Isn't the Apocrypha in the Bible?
Did Constantine Decide What Books Belong in the Bible?
What Occurred at the Council of Nicea?
"...[T]he authoritative teachings of Christ's historic Church are the final authority..."
Where your church's teachings conflict with the word of God, they are to be rejected (1 Tim. 6:35). You may reject them: Here (431, Proclamation that infant baptism regenerates the soul); and here (500, The Mass instituted as re-sacrifice of Jesus for the remission of sin); and here (593, Declaration that sin need to be purged, established by Pope Gregory I), and so on (Eph 4:14)...
"Nor do we go to heaven by denying and rejecting Christ's own historic Church..."
We don't go to heaven or hell based
on church affiliation. We go to heaven or hell based on a right relationship
with Jesus Christ (Isa
45:25;
53:11).
See:
A Scriptural Response to: Biblical Evidence or Catholics St. Joseph
Communication
"...[T]o reject one (the Church) is to reject the other (Jesus Christ) [Lk. 10:16]."
This town ain't big enough for the two of us." One of us is going to heaven and one of us is going to hell (Ga 1:6-8, Mt 15:9, Eph 4:14, Jude 11).
"...[Y]ou can't have a right relationship with Jesus Christ (the Head) while at the same time rejecting and attacking his own historic Church (the Body)."
The church (the body of Christ [Eph 4:16] will not accept your teaching (Jude 3).
[ Ecclesial Deism] "Fraid not. It's a direct deduction from your own stated position."
I am best a stating my own position.
[Using your (not your Pope's) brain] "And so I do---at least as much as you do."
There is no middle man. Obey God not man (Ac
5:29). God does not violate wisdom (1
Jn 5:20).
See:
Audio Pt
7a,
7b, From the Series:
Loving God with all your Heart by Dr. Darrell Ferguson
(right click, open)
No Mediator
"And Christ promised that the Holy Spirit would lead his
Church into all truth (Jn. 16:13)..."
You are not a member of the body of Christ. You reject
the gospel of grace. "Grace and peace", "grace and peace"--it is in that order
in scripture. First grace, then peace (Isa
48:22).
Salvation is by Christ (Isa
63:9;
Eph 5:23) and Christ
alone (Isa
45:21,22;
59:16;
Ac 4:12). It is of his
grace (Eph
2:5,8;
2 Ti 1:9;
Tit 2:11) through faith
in him (Mr
16:16;
Ac 16:31;
Ro 10:9;
Eph 2:8;
1Pe 1:5). Believe this (2
Sam. 22:31; Psa.
5:11; Psa.
7:1; Psa.
9:9, 10; Psa.
18:30; Psa.
32:10; Psa.
33:18, 19; Psa.
34:8, 22 vs. 18;; Psa.
2:12. Psa.
36:7; Psa.
40:4; Psa.
64:10; Psa.
78:7 vs. 57.; Psa.
84:5, 12; Psa.
112:5, 7, 8; Psa.
118:8, 9; Psa.
125:1; Psa.
147:11; Prov.
3:5; Prov.
14:26; Prov.
22:19; Prov.
28:25; Prov.
29:25; Prov.
30:5; Isa.
10:20; Isa.
14:32; Isa.
26:3; Isa.
30:15; Isa.
57:13; Jer.
17:7, 8; Jer.
39:18; Nah.
1:7; Matt.
9:22; Matt.
21:21, 22; Mark
9:23, 24; Mark
11:23, 24; Luke
7:50; Luke
8:4850; Luke
17:5; Luke
18:8; John
11:2527; Acts
3:16; Acts
13:48; Acts
26:18; Rom.
1:16, 17; Rom.
4:125; Rom.
5:1; Rom.
9:3133; Rom.
10:610; Rom.
11:20, 23; Rom.
15:13; 1
Cor. 1:21; 1
Cor. 2:5; 1
Cor. 12:8, 9; 2
Cor. 1:24; Gal.
3:129; Gal.
5:22; Eph.
2:8; Eph.
6:16; Col.
1:23; Col.
2:12; 1
Thess. 2:13; 1
Thess. 5:8; 2
Thess. 2:13; 1
Tim. 1:5, 19; 1
Tim. 2:15; 1
Tim. 4:10; 1
Tim. 6:11, 12, 17; 2
Tim. 4:7, 8; Heb.
4:111; Heb.
6:1, 7, 12, 18; Heb.
10:35, 38, 39; Heb.
11:13, 6; Heb.
13:5, 6; Jas.
1:6; Jas.
2:126; 1
Pet. 1:5, 7, 9, 21; 1
Pet. 3:5; 1
John 3:21; 1
John 5:4; Rev.
22:7).
You point to men, to your church, and to yourself (Pr
21:4,
Mt 6:5).
The Christian points to Christ.
All say no play (Jude
1:12).
Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come,
he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but
whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to
come.
He shall glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it unto you [John
16:1214].
"We dont know it all. We are to keep growing in grace and in the knowledge of
Him. How can we do it? Just reading the Bible is not the complete answer; the
Holy Spirit must be our Teacher as we read.
The Spirit of God is the Spirit of Truth. He will lead and guide you into all
truth. He guided the apostles just as the Lord said He would, and we find these
truths in the Epistles. The Spirit of God came to these men at Pentecost, and He
guided them in the truth both in their preaching and in their writing.
We can see how this was fulfilled in the apostles. The ministry of the Holy
Spirit has been to complete the teaching of the Lord Jesus Christ. The Epistles
glorify Christ and show Him as the Head of the church. They speak of His coming
again to establish His kingdom. The Epistles are the unfolding of the person and
ministry of Christ. They also tell of things to come and certainly the Book of
Revelation does this.
Notice the seven steps that are here: (1) The Holy Spirit, the Spirit of Truth,
has come; (2) He will guide you into all truth; (3) He will not speak of
Himself; (4) He shall speak whatsoever He shall hear; (5) He will show you
things to come; (6) He shall glorify Jesus; and (7) He shall receive of mine and
show it unto you.
Since we have been told these steps, we have a way of testing what we hear and
read. I listened to a man on a radio program saying, We are having a Holy Ghost
revival; the Holy Ghost is working; the Holy Ghost is doing this and that. The
minute he said all those things, I knew the Holy Ghost was not working. Why?
Because the Lord Jesus made it very clear that the Holy Ghost will not speak of
Himself. Then how can you tell when the Holy Spirit is working? He will glorify
Christ. My friend, when in a meeting or a Bible study you suddenly get a glimpse
of the Lord Jesus and He becomes wonderful, very real, and meaningful to you,
that is the working of the Holy Spirit. Jesus said, He shall glorify me."
McGee, J. Vernon: Thru the Bible Commentary. electronic ed. Nashville : Thomas
Nelson, 1997, c1981, S. 4:473-474
See:
A Scriptural Response to: Biblical Evidence or Catholics St. Joseph
Communication
"Every point after this has already been thoroughly answered in previous post..."
Already answered.
"...[Y]our slogan "Men lie""
When you don't learn what happens? Eph 4:19. Why do they become so wicked? Why do they become so sinful (e.g. raping little boys)? They are darkened (Eph 4:18). Ferguson. Mt 7:16.
"...[B]ishops are also guided infallibly..."
If that were true, neither Popes nor bishops would have
changed their minds. They would not have made oopsies here:
431 Proclamation that infant baptism regenerates the soul.
and here:
500 The Mass instituted as re-sacrifice of Jesus for the remission of sin
and here:
593 Declaration that sin need to be purged, established by Pope Gregory I
and here:
600 Prayers directed to Mary, dead saints, and angels.
and so on...
"Fortunately, none of the Church's formal teachings in any way "conflict with the word of God...""
Let the reader decide.
and here:
786 Worship of cross, images, and relics authorized.
and here:
995 Canonization of dead people as saints initiated by Pope John XV.
and here:
1000 Attendance at Mass made mandatory under the penalty of mortal sin.
and so on...
Response to comment [from a Christian]: [Ramblings about me] "Your love for that poster is evident. Not."
"I think he's talking to you." ~ Homer Simpson
[Strawman] "I was merely commenting on it."
You were using a fallacious argument--again.
"There is no middle man. Obey God not man."
You removed the scripture (Jn 1:1) from my quote [There is no middle man. Obey God not man (Ac 5:29).] It is what you do (Eph 4:14). :Shimei:
"Why, then, do you derive your ideas and beliefs from human sources (i.e, men)?"
You believe Popes. We believe God's word (Jn 1:1). God's word (not the Pope's word [Mt 15:9]) is the final word (Ps. 119:142, 151, 160 ).
"You point to men, to your church, and to yourself. The Christian points to Christ."
You removed the scripture from my quote (Jn 1:1) [You point to men, to your church, and to yourself (Pr 21:4, Mt 6:5). The Christian points to Christ.] It is what you do (Eph 4:14).
"McGee is completely wrong on this point."
If that were true you would be able to prove it from the word of God (Ac 17:11).
"The mere fact that serpent happens to disagree is entirely irrelevant."
The Roman Catholic Church does not have special knowledge that others cannot know. Gnostics taught this. The scriptures are full and sufficient (Lk 16:29,31), an unerring guide (Pr 6:23; 2 Pe 1:19), able to make men wise unto salvation through faith in Christ Jesus (2 Ti 3:15).
It was never designated as a "re-sacrifice of Jesus."
"One of the most unbelievable, yet fiercely held, traditions of the Roman Catholic Church is its dogma of transubstantiation. First pronounced at the Fourth Lateran Council in l2l5 AD, it declares the entire substance of bread and wine is transformed into the actual body and blood of the Lord Jesus Christ Each Catholic priest is said to have the Spirit's power to call Jesus down from heaven through this miracle of transubstantiation. Thus Jesus becomes physically present on Catholic altars so that priests can offer Him again to the Father for the sins of the living and the dead. After the offering, God is eaten by Catholics when they ingest the Eucharist. Without question, the Roman Catholic Church regards Christ's real presence in the Eucharist a dogma of utmost importance. According to paragraph1324 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC), the Eucharist is "the source and summit of the Christian life." It teaches us: "the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity, of our Lord Jesus Christ and, therefore, the whole Christ is truly, really, and substantially contained" in the Eucharist (CCC, 1374). This is a non-negotiable dogma because the Council of Trent placed a curse or anathema on anyone who does not believe it (Canon 1). Furthermore, Catholics must consume the Eucharist because it is a necessary requirement for their salvation (CCC, 1359). If Catholic priests can indeed change bread and wine into the body and blood of the infinite Christ, and if indeed consuming His body and blood is necessary for salvation, then the whole world must become Roman Catholic to be saved from the wrath of God..." Full text: No Sacrifice
"Catholics do not "worship" sacred images and objects..."
"Roman Catholics attempt to "bypass" these clear Scriptural principles by claiming they do not worship Mary or saints, but rather that they only "venerate" Mary and the saints. Using a different word does not change the essence of what is being done. A definition of "venerate" is "to regard with respect or reverence." Nowhere in the Bible are we told to revere anyone but God alone..." Full text: No Mary Worship
"Are you pathologically incapable of accurately representing Catholic doctrine and practice?"
We understand it and reject it. You do not admit that even one of these traditions is unbiblical. They are all unbiblical. It goes against logic and reason to continue to believe them but the Roman Catholic Church said to. You are in rebellion toward God and his word (Jn 1:1, Jude 11).
"Now go ahead and actually prove your claim."
I provided proof
when I stated: God is sovereign (Dan.
4:25,
35;
Rom. 9:1523;
1 Tim. 6:15;
Rev. 4:11). His word is
living and active in the life of the believer (Heb.
4:12). The Lord continues to build his church (Mt
16:18). God's word (not your
perversion and inversion of it) is effectual (Is.
55:11).
"I'm finished with this guy..." ~ Vinny Gambini
"The rest of serpent's comments are..."
Poisoning the well. I have not made the rest of my comments yet.
"...of him repeating the same already-answered..."
Non causae ut causae (claiming victory despite defeat)
"...logical errors..."
You're projecting again. Hang in there. We know one of these days you will be able to form a sentence without a fallacious argument.
"...and unsubstantiated assertions..."
The word of God proves you wrong (Jn 1:1, Ps. 119:142, 151, 160).
Response to comment [from other]: "How was he fallacious?"
You said you taught logic. Were your students stuffed animals?
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: [Strawman] "No you didn't."
You said that I believed in the "...ancient heresy of
Ecclesial Deism..."
I said:
"God is sovereign (Dan.
4:25,
35;
Rom. 9:1523;
1 Tim. 6:15;
Rev. 4:11). His word is
living and active in the life of the believer (Heb.
4:12). The Lord continues to build his church (Mt
16:18). God's word (not your
perversion and inversion of it) is effectual (Is.
55:11)."
Again, you attempt to conflate two issues.
"Try to focus..."
You're projecting again (Eph 4:14). Is your sin catching up to you? Nu 32:23
Don't check your brains at the door (1
Jn 5:20).
Reasons last step is the recognition that there are an infinite number of
things which are beyond it....The heart has its reasons, which reason does not
know at all ~ Blaise Pascal
See:
Blaise Pascal: Scientific and spiritual prodigy
Recommended Reading:
Don't Check Your Brains at the Door: A Book of Christian Evidences (Know What
You Believe and Why) by Josh McDowell and Bob
Hostetler
[You said that I believed in the "...ancient heresy of Ecclesial Deism...] "And so you do..."
Ad hominem (Eph 4:14).
"Your accusation here is an ad hominem..."
You made the accusation. You were proven wrong by may actual belief: God is sovereign (Dan. 4:25, 35; Rom. 9:1523; 1 Tim. 6:15; Rev. 4:11). His word is living and active in the life of the believer (Heb. 4:12). The Lord continues to build his church (Mt 16:18). God's word (not your :olinger: perversion and inversion of it) is effectual (Is. 55:11).
"In any case, you've already been answered..."
Non causae ut causae (claiming victory despite defeat)
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: "You don't know what an ad hom is."
Ad hominem.
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: [You made the accusation.] "Nope. You accused me of engaging in an ad hominem fallacy."
That's correct.
"Now you've merely resorted to lying again..."
Let the reader decide.
Summary
You argue like
a
typical Catholic.
See:
Seeking His Truth: Letters of Rebuke, Affirmation and Encouragement, pg. 4
Response to comment [from a Christian]: "...The authoritative teaching of the Word of God is the result of reading studying, prayerful consideration and believing..."
Do you reject the trinity? Mt 3:16,17; 28:19; Ro 8:9; 1Co 12:3-6; 2Co 13:14; Eph 4:4-6; 1Pe 1:2; Jude 1:20,21; Re 1:4,5.
The scriptures
guide the believer (Ps.
119:133).
[[Rescuing Precious Souls from the Bondage of Religion Proclaiming the Gospel
Ministries] "We can be wrong about a lot of things in this life and still
survive, but if we are wrong about the only way to obtain forgiveness from God,
we will pay for that fatal mistake throughout all eternity. Our Creator provides
only one way to redeem man from sin and He has revealed it in a divinely
inspired message to mankind. However, it didn't take long for God's complete and
perfect Gospel message to be corrupted by religious leaders. These men, who say
they speak for God, have distorted and perverted this good news of God's mercy
and grace. Their unstated goal has been to control people by keeping them in
legalistic bondage to their authority. The Lord Jesus revealed the only way of
escape from this bondage. He said: "If you abide in My word, then you are truly
disciples of Mine; and you shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you
free" (John
8:31-32)." Full text:
Rescuing Precious Souls from the Bondage of Religion
"When you did not know God, you were slaves to those which by nature are not
gods." (Gal.
4:8)
"James 2:21,22,23,24...[W]hat is the Protestant approach to the Bible?"
We believe the
Bible (Jas
1:18).
"2:21 justified by works. This does not contradict Pauls
clear teaching that Abraham was justified before God by grace alone through
faith alone (Rom.
3:20;
4:125;
Gal. 3:6,11).
For several reasons, James cannot mean that Abraham was constituted righteous
before God because of his own good works: 1) James already stressed that
salvation is a gracious gift (1:17,18); 2) in the middle of this disputed
passage (v. 23), James quoted
Gen. 15:6, which
forcefully claims that God credited righteousness to Abraham solely on the basis
of his faith (see notes on
Rom. 1:17;
3:24;
4:125); and 3) the work
that James said justified Abraham was his offering up of Isaac (Gen.
22:9,12),
an event that occurred many years after he first exercised faith and was
declared righteous before God (Gen.
12:17;
15:6). Instead, Abrahams
offering of Isaac demonstrated the genuineness of his faith and the reality of
his justification before God. James is emphasizing the vindication before others
of a mans claim to salvation. James teaching perfectly complements Pauls
writings; salvation is determined by faith alone (Eph.
2:8,9)
and demonstrated by faithfulness to obey Gods will alone (Eph.
2:10).
2:22 was made perfect. This refers to bringing something to its end, or to its
fullness. Just as a fruit tree has not arrived at its goal until it bears fruit,
faith has not reached its end until it demonstrates itself in a righteous life.
2:23 the Scripture
says. Quoted from
Gen. 15:6; see notes on
Rom. 4:15. friend of
God. Abraham is so called in
2 Chr. 20:7 and
Is. 41:8 because of his
obedience (John
15:14,15).
2:24 justified by works, and not by faith only. See note on v. 21." MacArthur,
John Jr: The MacArthur Study Bible. electronic ed. Nashville : Word Pub., 1997,
c1997, S.
Jas 2:21
See:
A Scriptural Response to: Biblical Evidence or Catholics
St. Joseph Communication
[Establish the Supreme Authority for Truth Proclaiming the Gospel Ministries]
"Reaching those who are being held captive by religious indoctrination must
always begin by establishing the Bible as the supreme authority for knowing
God's Gospel. Christ and His Word must rule over man's religious traditions
because God has exalted His Word above all things (Psalm
138:2). The word of God is infallible and has
no equal (Isa.
55:10). The Bible is the most authoritative,
influential and powerful book ever written. It is the standard for discerning
truth from error (1
John 4:6). It is sufficient to function as the
sole, infallible rule of faith (2
Tim. 3:14-16). The Bible does not refer us to
any other rule of faith because everything we must know, understand and believe
to be reconciled to God is found in Scripture (1
Cor. 15:1-4). Whenever we are confronted by two
or more opinions, we must always ask, "But what does the Scripture say?" (Gal.
4:30)." Full text:
Establish the Supreme Authority for Truth
"...[Y]ou keeping adding "faith alone" to Scripture..."
We are saved by grace alone (Eph 2:8-9), through faith alone (Eph 1:13; 2Ti 1:10), in Christ alone (Isa 45:21,22; 59:16; Ac 4:12). Roman Catholics deny this (Jude 1:11).
[Eph 2:8-10]
"2:8 faith, and that not of yourselves.
That refers to the entire previous statement of salvation, not only the grace
but the faith. Although men are required to believe for salvation, even that
faith is part of the gift of God which saves and cannot be exercised by ones
own power. Gods grace is preeminent in every aspect of salvation (cf.
Rom. 3:20;
Gal. 2:16).
2:10 created in
for good works. Good works cannot produce salvation but are
subsequent and resultant God-empowered fruits and evidences of it (cf.
John 15:8;
Phil. 2:12,
13;
2 Tim. 3:17;
Titus 2:14;
James 2:1626). which God
prepared beforehand. Like his salvation, a believers sanctification and good
works were ordained before time began (see notes on
Rom. 8:29,
30)." MacArthur, John Jr:
The MacArthur Study Bible. electronic ed. Nashville : Word Pub., 1997, c1997, S.
Eph 2:8
See:
A Scriptural Response to: Biblical Evidence or Catholics St. Joseph
Communication
[What About The Traditions of Men? Proclaiming the Gospel
Ministries]: "Roman Catholics reject the supreme authority of Scripture by
elevating their tradition to the same level of authority. They defend their
position by quoting St. Paul who wrote: "Stand firm and hold to the traditions
which you were taught, whether by word of mouth or by letter from us" (2
Thes. 2:15). But we must make a distinction
between traditions which had already been taught by the apostles in the first
century and the traditions established by men over the last 1900 years (2
Cor. 11:2 ;
2 Thes. 3:6).
Clearly there are certain apostolic traditions recorded in Scripture that
Christians must embrace, but not all traditions are biblical. Paul encouraged us
to make this distinction. He wrote: "See to it that no one takes you captive
through philosophy and empty deception, according to the tradition of men,
according to the elementary principles of the world, rather than according to
Christ" (Col.
2:8). Paul is warning us that we can become
ensnared by the traditions of men when they do not conform to Christ and His
word. Tradition must always be subservient to Scripture because God's word is
divinely inspired while tradition is not." Full text:
What About The Traditions of Men?
[We are saved by grace alone (Eph 2:8-9), through faith alone (Eph 1:13; 2Ti 1:10), in Christ alone (Isa 45:21,22; 59:16; Ac 4:12). Roman Catholics deny this (Jude 1:11).] "...[N]ot according to Scripture...."
Not when scripture is rejected (Jer 8:9, Jn 1:1).
"Lk 10:25,26,27,28, James 2:21,22,23,24"
Argument Ad Nauseam or Ad infinitum
(Repetition)
See:
A Scriptural Response to: Biblical Evidence or Catholics St. Joseph
Communication
[2:8 faith, and that not of yourselves. That refers to the entire previous statement of salvation, not only the grace but the faith. Although men are required to believe for salvation, even that faith is part of the gift of God which saves and cannot be exercised by ones own power. Gods grace is preeminent in every aspect of salvation (cf. Rom. 3:20; Gal. 2:16).] "...[T]he Bible doesn't say that..."
"Not of works" means "of works" Eph 2:9
See:
Works vs. Faith
[What About "Infallible" Men? Proclaiming the Gospel Ministries]: "Roman
Catholics also reject the supreme authority of Scripture by elevating its
"infallible" bishops to be equal in authority. In practice, the bishops actually
sit above Scripture by declaring no one else can give an authentic
interpretation of the Word of God (Catechism of the Catholic Church, para. 85).
Yet the Apostle Paul commended the Bereans (who were not bishops) for
interpreting the Scriptures to verify the truthfulness of his teaching. "Now the
Bereans...received the message with great eagerness and examined the Scriptures
every day to see if what Paul said was true" (Acts 17:11). It is quite clear
that the apostle, who penned over half the New Testament, encouraged his
listeners to submit to the supreme authority of the Hebrew Scriptures. The
veracity of every man's message must be tested with the same Scriptural
authority." Full text:
What About "Infallible" Men?
There are not two gospels.
There is one gospel (Ac
20:24).
[Getting the Gospel Right Proclaiming the Gospel Ministries]: "Once the supreme
authority of Scripture has been communicated to Catholics who are enslaved to
another authority, the Gospel of God can be heralded. It is wise to present
God's Gospel in contrast to Rome's plan of salvation so Catholics can discern
the difference. The distinction between the two gospels can best be described as
the difference between divine accomplishment and human achievement. The true
Gospel describes what God has done through Jesus Christ to save sinners, while
the gospel of Rome describes what man must do for God. Paul defines the Gospel
according to Scripture alone (1
Cor. 15:1-4). The glorious Gospel of grace is
what one perfect man did 2000 years ago to reconcile sinful man to God. It has
nothing to do with what any imperfect man has done since, or is doing now. This
eliminates all the requirements Roman Catholics have added to the finished work
of Jesus Christ. It also eliminates Catholic priests making daily sin offerings
on their altars." Full text:
Getting the Gospel Right
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: "How is it that you presume to have any real knowledge or understanding of "what the Church preaches...""
People can understand your theology
and reject it as unbiblical.
[Catholics Are Totally Dependent Upon An Illegitimate Priesthood Proclaiming the
Gospel Ministries]: "One of the most controlling elements of the Roman Catholic
religion is its indoctrination concerning the priesthood. Each Catholic is
taught that their salvation is utterly dependent upon the ministry of their
priests. According to the unbiblical teachings of Rome, it is the Catholic
priest who baptizes infants for their justification and spiritual birth, the
priest who hears confession and demands penance as the satisfaction for sin, the
priest who dispenses Jesus in the Eucharist, the priest who imparts the Holy
Spirit in the sacrament of Confirmation, the priest who gives Last Rites, and
the priest who offers the sacrifice of the Mass for souls suffering in
purgatory. What a fatal deception!
There is no longer a need for priests offering sacrifices for sin because by one
offering Jesus Christ has perfected for all time those who are sanctified (Heb.
10:14). At the very moment our Lord Jesus gave
up His Spirit on Calvary's cross, the veil of the temple was torn in two from
top to bottom (Mat.
27:51). The veil that separated sinful man from
the Holy of Holies was ripped open, and now, anyone washed by the blood of
Christ can come boldly into the presence of God. When Jesus, our High Priest,
offered Himself once for all sin for all time, he made the sacrificial
priesthood obsolete. Every believer in Jesus Christ has been sanctified through
the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all (Heb.
10:10).
The illegitimacy and obsolescence of the Roman Catholic priesthood is also
expressly noted by the sovereign and exclusive work of the triune God in saving
sinners. It is God the Father who chooses, calls and draws the lost to His Son (John
6:44;
Jas. 2:5). The Holy
Spirit convicts them of their sin and the coming judgment (John
16:8-11). Jesus Christ is proclaimed through
His Word as the only way of salvation (John
14:6). God gives life to those dead in sin and
grants the sinner repentance and faith (Rom.
4:17;
Eph. 2:8-9;
2 Tim. 2:25). Jesus
exchanges His righteousness for the sins of the believer (2
Cor. 5:21). The Holy Spirit seals, indwells and
empowers the justified believer (Eph.
1:13-14, Rom. 8). The Father adopts, secures
and glorifies His children (John
1:12;
Rom. 8:30). Clearly, God
alone is deserving of all glory! (Rom.
11:36). He alone is worthy to be praised!" Full
text:
Catholics Are Totally Dependent Upon An Illegitimate Priesthood
"...[Y]our comment is entirely irrelevant..."
God's word is relevant (Jer.
23:28).
[How Can We Rescue These Precious Souls? Proclaiming the Gospel Ministries]:
"Paul provides the answer! "The Lord's bondservant must not be quarrelsome, but
be kind to all, able to teach, patient when wronged, with gentleness correcting
those who are in opposition, if perhaps God may grant them repentance leading to
the knowledge of the truth, and they may come to their senses and escape from
the snare of the devil, having been held captive by him to do his will" (2
Tim. 2:24-26). We must take note of the correct
way to approach those who are being deceived by the clever, scheming, and subtle
lies of the devil. We must lovingly confront them with gentleness, patience and
humility and avoid being quarrelsome or argumentative. As we correct them, we
must use the Scriptures and avoid giving our own opinions, experiences or
philosophy. Saving faith comes from hearing the Word (Rom.
10:17).
Liberty from the bondage of sin and deception is found only in Christ. The
Father sent Him to preach the Gospel to the poor, to proclaim release to the
captives and to set free those who are downtrodden (Luke
4:18). Jesus also came to give sight to the
blind because a veil of spiritual blindness covers every man's heart. However
there is one condition that must be met: Paul declares: "whenever a man turns to
the Lord, the veil is taken away" (2
Cor. 3:16). This means turning from fallible
men and their traditions and turning to Christ and His infallible word!" Full
text:
How Can We Rescue These Precious Souls?
"...[Y]our comment is entirely irrelevant..."
God's word is relevant (Psa. 50:16, 17; Prov. 1:29, 30; Prov. 13:13; Isa. 5:24; Isa. 28:914; Isa. 30:911; Isa. 53:1; Jer. 6:10; Jer. 8:9; Hos. 8:12; Amos 2:12; Mic. 2:6; Luke 16:31; Luke 24:25; John 3:20; John 5:46, 47; John 8:37, 45; 1 Cor. 1:18, 22, 23; 2 Tim. 3:8; 2 Tim. 4:3, 4; 1 Pet. 2:8; 2 Pet. 3:15, 16; Rev. 22:19).
"God's word is relevant."
You removed the scripture from my quote.
It is what you do (Eph
4:14).
God's word is relevant (Psa.
50:16, 17; Prov.
1:29, 30; Prov.
13:13; Isa.
5:24; Isa.
28:914; Isa.
30:911; Isa.
53:1; Jer.
6:10; Jer.
8:9; Hos.
8:12; Amos
2:12; Mic.
2:6; Luke
16:31; Luke
24:25; John
3:20; John
5:46, 47; John
8:37, 45; 1
Cor. 1:18, 22, 23; 2
Tim. 3:8; 2
Tim. 4:3, 4; 1
Pet. 2:8; 2
Pet. 3:15, 16; Rev.
22:19).
The word of God is effectual in the life of the believer (Is.
55:11).
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: [Removing scripture from my quotes] "And why do I do this?..."
You don't have Christ (Eph 4:14, 2 Cor. 13:35).
Response to comment [from a "Christian"]: "...[A]nd "eternal life is rendered according to works" Rom 2:6,7..."
You will appear at the Great White Throne Judgment because
you believe a works-based gospel (Jude 11). We will go the the Bema seat because
we believe in a grace-based gospel. You will not stand
because you have no righteousness of your own. We will
because we do not trust in our own righteousness (Isa 61:10). We trust in
Christ's righteousness (Ro 3:22).
See:
Satan, Inc. (TOL's heretic's list)
Who will render to every man according to his deeds [Rom. 2:6].
"He shall reward every man according to his works. Absolute justice is the
criterion of the judgment or rewards. Mans deeds stand before God in His holy
light. No man in his right mind wants to be judged on this basis. Remember
Corneliushe was a good man, but he was lost." McGee, J. Vernon: Thru the Bible
Commentary. electronic ed. Nashville : Thomas Nelson, 1997, c1981, S. 4:657-658
"2:610 See notes on 2:116. Although Scripture everywhere teaches that
salvation is not on the basis of works (see notes on 4:14; Eph. 2:8, 9), it
consistently teaches that Gods judgment is always on the basis of a mans deeds
(Is. 3:10, 11; Jer. 17:10; John 5:28, 29; 1 Cor. 3:8; 2 Cor. 5:10; Gal. 6:79;
cf. Rom. 14:12). Paul describes the deeds of two distinct groups: the redeemed
(vv. 7, 10) and the unredeemed (vv. 8, 9). The deeds of the redeemed are not the
basis of their salvation but the evidence of it. They are not perfect and are
prone to sin, but there is undeniable evidence of righteousness in their lives
(see notes on James 2:1420, 26)." MacArthur, John Jr: The MacArthur Study
Bible. electronic ed. Nashville : Word Pub., 1997, c1997, S. Ro 2:6
See:
What is the Great White Throne Judgment?
What is the Judgment Seat of Christ / Bema Seat of Christ?
"I'll just accept Scripture..."
If you accepted scripture (Jn
1:1), you would tell the truth (Ga
2:16,
Ro 3:20,
3:28). Seek first his
kingdom and his righteousness (Mt
6:33).
See:
A Scriptural Response to: Biblical Evidence or Catholics St. Joseph
Communication
"[A]men..."
Amen means we agree. We do not (Eph 4:14).
See:
Works vs Faith
[Eph 4:14] "That verse doesn't say that."
"4:14 carried about with every wind of doctrine.
Spiritually immature believers who are not grounded in the knowledge of Christ
through Gods Word are inclined to uncritically accept every sort of beguiling
doctrinal error and fallacious interpretation of Scripture promulgated by
deceitful, false teachers in the church. They must learn discernment (1
Thess. 5:21,
22). See 3:1; 14:20. The
NT is replete with warnings of such danger (Acts
20:30,
31;
Rom. 16:17,
18;
Gal. 1:6,
7;
1 Tim. 4:17;
2 Tim. 2:1518;
2 Pet. 2:13)."
MacArthur, John Jr: The MacArthur Study Bible. electronic ed. Nashville : Word
Pub., 1997, c1997, S.
Eph 4:14
"His goal for believers (4:1216):
That they be equipped (4:12)
That they be mature (4:13)
That they be settled (4:1416)"Willmington, H. L.: The Outline Bible. Wheaton,
Ill. : Tyndale House Publishers, 1999, S.
Eph 4:14-16
[Eph 4:14 carried about with every wind of doctrine...] "[D]o you mean the reformation?" [21 Dec 2011 23:23:15]
Check what Protestants and Catholics say with the word of God (Ac 17:11).
Response to comment [from a Catholic]: "...[O]ne of the Protestant posters on this board asserts that he goes by the Bible alone yet repeatedly refused to answer questions or even to affirm certain Scriptures..."
A few housekeeping items:
When you don't like the biblical answer (Jn 1:1, Jn 3:19),
you tend to claim that your concerns are not addressed.
You claimed that you did not get a sufficient
response on Ro 2:6-7.
You claimed that you did not get a sufficient
response on Heb 6:1, 2; Ac 8:17, 19:6.
You claimed that you did not get a sufficient response to
DA Carson's writing.
To understand the Bible, you are going to need the Holy Spirit.
Get yourself a savior (Mt 6:33) and then re-read.
"When you educate without the Holy Spirit you only get a clever devil."
~ Adrain Rogers
Jesus loves you (Jn 3:16). Jesus is willing to save you (2 Pe 3:9). Repent (Eze
18:30-32; Ac 17:30). Believe (Mk 9:23).
"I'm workin' with ya on this thing..." ~ Jerry Lundegaard "
"[D]o you affirm Rom 2:6,7..."
Argument Ad Nauseam or Ad infinitum (Repetition) link
"[W]hat does it mean to seek immortality through good works? Rom 2:6,7..."
Argument Ad Nauseam or Ad infinitum (Repetition) link
"...Lk 10: 25,26,27,28"
You will not receive eternal life by doing good works (Gal.
1:68). Your "good works" are insufficient for
salvation (Psa.
49:7, 8; Psa.
127:1, 2; Eccl.
1:14; Isa.
43:26; Isa.
57:12; Isa.
64:6; Ezek.
7:19; Ezek.
33:1219; Dan.
9:18; Matt.
5:20; Luke
17:710; Luke
18:914; Acts
13:39; Rom.
3:2031; Rom.
4:18 vs. 922.; Rom.
8:3; Rom.
9:16, 31, 32; Rom.
11:6; 1
Cor. 13:13; Gal.
2:16, 19, 21; Gal.
3:1012, 21 vs. 129.; Gal.
4:911; Gal.
5:2, 4, 6, 18; Gal.
6:15; Eph.
2:8, 9; Phil.
3:39; Col.
2:2023; 2
Tim. 1:9; Tit.
3:4, 5; Heb.
4:310; Heb.
6:1, 2; Heb.
9:114; Jas.
2:10, 11).
Plans and programs to do not save.
Jesus saves (Isa
63:9;
Eph 5:23). Jesus alone
saves (Isa
45:21,22;
59:16;
Ac 4:12).
See:
Jesus Gives Parable of the Good Samaritan
"...[T]he human traditional article you gave did not address the point in question: namely the giving of the Holy Spirit through human hands/works Heb 6:1,2, Acts 8:17, Acts 19:6"
Argument Ad Nauseam or Ad infinitum (Repetition)
link
People are able to read and understand the Bible (2 Ti 3:16,17).
That is why God gave it (2 Ti 3:15).
"...[Y]ou don't affirm Rom 2:6,7 in that link. [W]hy won't you affirm that eternal life is rendered to each according to their works?"
Argument Ad Nauseam or Ad infinitum (Repetition)
link
"I affirmed Eph 2:8,9, and showed that is what the N .T. Church Council
of Trent said..."
Don't quote
Eph 2:8-9 without (v.
10). We are saved unto good works (Eph
2:10). Your religion is work-based (Gal.
1:68).
Christianity is faith-based (Ro
4:16).
It's not about your work. It's about his (Ac
11:21;
1 Co 2:5).
See:
Works vs Faith
What to "Do"
"[D]o you wish that Rom 2:6,7 wasn't in the Bible?..."
Argument Ad Nauseam or Ad infinitum (Repetition) Eph 4:14
link
Posted By patricius79:
what do you personally think of Rom 2:6,7?
do you wish that Rom 2:6,7 wasn't in the Bible? ...
do you wish that Rom 2:6,7 wasn't in the Bible?
you don't affirm Rom 2:6,7 in that link why...
you don't affirm Rom 2:6,7 in that link...
why won't you affirm that eternal life is rendered to each according to their
works?
what does it mean to seek immortality through good works? Rom 2:6,7
so you do affirm Rom 2:6,7 as such? cf. 1...
so you do affirm Rom 2:6,7 as such?
why do you refuse to affirm some Scripture?
why do you refuse to affirm some Scripture?
if you won't affirm Rom 2:6,7, then why do you attack the Biblical Church?
you are refusing to affirm Rom 2:6,7? Cf. 1...
you are refusing to affirm Rom 2:6,7?
Etc.